Case Nears Verdict as O’Neal’s ARPA Message and Martinez’s ‘Butler Service’ Text Take Center Stage

The federal corruption trial of Ray Martinez and Jenifer O’Neal entered its fifth day on Tuesday, and the courtroom has moved toward a turning point. Both sides rested—for now—but the case could reopen if Martinez chooses to testify. Closing arguments are set for early Wednesday afternoon, with a verdict possible as soon as late tonight if deliberations move quickly, though Thursday remains more likely

Judge Prepares for Closings Under Rule 611

Judge Mark Kearney told attorneys he will rely on Federal Rule of Evidence 611 to keep Wednesday’s closings focused and within time limits. Under the rule, the prosecution will argue first, followed by the defense, and the government will receive a final rebuttal because it carries the burden of proof.

Rule 611 also gives the judge authority to stop improper arguments — including misstating evidence or law, appealing to prejudice, or introducing facts not in evidence.

Defense Pushes for Acquittals Under Rule 29

Before resting, both defense teams invoked Rule 29, which allows a judge to dismiss charges if the evidence presented by the government is legally insufficient.

Martinez’s attorneys asked for dismissal on Counts 1–5, 6, 8, 9, and 10.